The rise of prosecutions in high-income countries


  • RT @ZackFord: In Georgia, black men are far more likely to be arrested under HIV criminalization laws and then nearly twice as likely to be… 11 Jan 2018
  • After two years of our coalition, we’re really getting somewhere: here’s to even more HIV JUSTICE WORLDWIDE in 2018… 19 Dec 2017
  • Watch and learn about the first ever European Legal Environments Training Academy (#ELETA) at... 10 Dec 2017
  • HIV JUSTICE WORLDWIDE is conducting a short, rapid survey on mandatory HIV disclosure in healthcare settings across… 07 Dec 2017
  • RT @CtrHIVLawPolicy: Coming Up: @NACDL and CHLP to Co-Host Webinar on HIV Criminalization: Thursday, December 7, 2017… 07 Dec 2017
  • RT @VIHnoesCrimenMx: 29 estados tipifican, en sus Códigos Penales, el "contagio" o "riesgo de contagio"de VIH y otras ITS, criminalizando a… 07 Dec 2017
  • RT @EbaPatrick: .@Lzloures says #discrimination in health among great barriers to #UHC. Exclusion harms us all #ICASA2017 @KELINKenya @kent07 Dec 2017
  • RT @Follow_SALC: #ICASA2017 #HIVHumanRights consultation starts with Lynette Mabote @_ARASAcomms lamenting the inadequate inclusion of huma… 07 Dec 2017
  • RT @Follow_SALC: #ICASA2017 Felicita @_ARASAcomms & @MalecheAllan @KELINKenya human rights activists fighting for ending legal barriers to… 07 Dec 2017
  • RT @_ARASAcomms: ARASA attending African Francophone lawyers Consultation on Criminalization of HIV, supported by #RobertCarrNetworkFund &,… 07 Dec 2017
  • HIV Is Not a Crime / VIH No Es un Crimen (Mexico, Oct 2017): via @YouTube 07 Dec 2017
  • RT @Uganetlaw: UGANET renew call against HIV Criminalization this #WAD2017 @_ARASAcomms @KELINKenya @HealthRightsEA @ICWEastAfrica https:/… 04 Dec 2017
  • RT @AIDS_Free_World: Participerez-vous à la Conférence internationale sur le sida et les IST en Afrique à Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire? Nous vous… 04 Dec 2017
  • RT @AIDS_Free_World: AIDS-Free World will be at @icasa2017, hosting a Legal Consultation Center. Find us at Booth 22 &23 in the Community V… 04 Dec 2017
  • RT @AIDS_Free_World: Heading to @icasa2017? Dec. 4-9, AIDS-Free World is hosting a Legal Consultation Center at #ICASA2017, where delegates… 01 Dec 2017
  • Russia: Fundraising appeal to appoint new lawyer for 18-year-old woman prosecuted for alleged HIV exposure. To help… 28 Nov 2017
  • Malawi: Human Rights Activists celebrate adoption of amended HIV Law that removes rights-infringing provisions. Rea… 28 Nov 2017
  • RT @Follow_SALC: #MalawiHIVBill activists celebrate a victory for human rights as MPs reject criminalizing and punitive provisions @saraich28 Nov 2017
  • RT @Follow_SALC: #MalawiHIVBill Parliament says a definitive NO to HIV Criminalisation, no to mandatory testing, no to pre-employment testi… 28 Nov 2017
  • RT @LaurelDSprague: Huge congratulations to the BRILLIANT FIERCE #persistentadvocates in Malawi. #HIVCriminalization is not an acceptable c… 28 Nov 2017

Other wealthy countries with low overall HIV prevalence soon found themselves wrestling with similar policy options, with similarly wide variation in legal and policy responses.

The world’s first known conviction of a person for unprotected consensual sex without disclosure of his HIV-positive status occurred in the former West Germany (now the Federal Republic of Germany) in 1987. The case involved a 46-year-old American civilian who worked as a cook at a United States army base in Nuremburg, Bavaria. The defendant had acknowledged having sexual intercourse with at least three other men after learning that he was HIV-positive, but denied he intended to harm anyone. He received a two-year prison sentence “for attempting to inflict ‘grievous bodily harm’ by practicing unprotected sex.”1  Of note, the man’s arrest had immediately followed “the widely publicized announcement of stiff measures against the spread of the AIDS virus in the southern state of Bavaria.”1

Beginning in 1989, Canada used existing criminal laws to prosecute HIV-positive people for having otherwise consensual sex without disclosing their HIV status, with charges including criminal negligence causing bodily harm; common nuisance; assault; administering a noxious thing; and attempted murder.2  The number of prosecutions increased substantially following a 1998 Supreme Court ruling that if an HIV-positive person does not disclose his or her status before engaging in otherwise consensual sexual conduct that poses a ‘significant risk’ of HIV transmission, then the partner’s consent is invalid, thereby rendering the sex an assault in law.3

Early prosecutions in Australia reveal a complex pattern. Nine of the twelve known cases between 1991 and 2001 occurred in Victoria (one of eight jurisdictions), with one charge laid in each of three other states/territories. The first two known charges (‘reckless endangerment’) were laid against two sex workers (a man and a woman) but charges were dropped immediately before the committal hearing.

Possibly the world’s first-ever murder conviction for sexual HIV transmission took place in Italy in 2000, when an Italian man was found guilty of ‘culpable homicide’ for infecting his wife who subsequently died. There are no details regarding how the court proved his state of mind or whether he pleaded guilty or was found guilty following a trial. He was sentenced to 14 years in prison.

The next person was charged in 1993 for having unprotected sex without disclosing his HIV status. The defendant died between the committal hearing and the trial.4 Subsequent prosecutions, all relating to unprotected sex without disclosure, also “went unrealised or were overturned (but resulted in considerable media and public resentment), basically as a result of the low risk of transmission associated with individual sexual encounters.”5 The first conviction was obtained in 1998.6 The defendant was a 52-year-old bisexual man who was found guilty of having oral and anal sex with three men, two of whom tested HIV-positive. He committed suicide in prison.

By 2005, at least 36 European countries had either HIV-specific criminal laws or had used existing criminal laws to prosecute HIV exposure or transmission, and 21 had successfully prosecuted at least one person. However, just three European countries – Austria, Sweden and Switzerland – accounted for more than 60% of the total convictions, each having prosecuted more than 30 people living with HIV with cases starting in 1990, 1992 and 1998, respectively. Prosecutions in Europe were primarily for non-coercive sexual exposure or transmission.7


  1. New York Times Bavarian court convicts American in AIDS case. 17 November, 1987
  2. Elliot R Criminal law & HIV/AIDS: final report. Montreal: Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network/Canadian AIDS Society, 1996
  3. Elliott R After Cuerrier: Canadian criminal law and the non-disclosure of HIV-positive status. Montreal: Canadian HIV/AIDS Legal Network, 1999
  4. Cameron S Research undertaken for the Australian National Association of People Living with HIV/AIDS, unpublished, 2009
  5. Woodroffe M Criminal transmission of HIV in Australia. in Cameron S and Rule J (eds), The Criminalisation of HIV Transmission in Australia: legality, morality and reality NAPWA, 2009
  6. Houlihan A, (Ill-Legal) Lust is a Battle Field: HIV risk, socio-sexuality and criminality. Law and Society Association Australia and New Zealand (LSAANZ) Conference, Sydney, 2008
  7. GNP+, THT Criminalisation of HIV transmission in Europe. Available online at:, 2005
This content was checked for accuracy at the time it was written. It may have been superseded by more recent developments. NAM recommends checking whether this is the most current information when making decisions that may affect your health.
Community Consensus Statement on Access to HIV Treatment and its Use for Prevention

Together, we can make it happen

We can end HIV soon if people have equal access to HIV drugs as treatment and as PrEP, and have free choice over whether to take them.

Launched today, the Community Consensus Statement is a basic set of principles aimed at making sure that happens.

The Community Consensus Statement is a joint initiative of AVAC, EATG, MSMGF, GNP+, HIV i-Base, the International HIV/AIDS Alliance, ITPC and NAM/aidsmap

This content was checked for accuracy at the time it was written. It may have been superseded by more recent developments. NAM recommends checking whether this is the most current information when making decisions that may affect your health.

NAM’s information is intended to support, rather than replace, consultation with a healthcare professional. Talk to your doctor or another member of your healthcare team for advice tailored to your situation.