“HIV is a virus, not a crime"

Edwin J. Bernard
Published: 18 July 2010

Twitter

  • DeBalie is filling fast so register now for Beyond Blame 2018: Challenging HIV Criminalisation, Amsterdam, Monday 2… https://t.co/FTA2WzVjt0 24 May 2018
  • RT @KELINKenya: .@AIDS_Free_World’s Legal Consultation Centers provide delegates and the public with free with attorneys on #HIV & law. Are… 23 May 2018
  • We're almost half-full already, so if you want to share your experiences, or learn more about, ending HIV criminali… https://t.co/skvEu5Z3yY 23 May 2018
  • RT @HIVJusticeNet: Register now for #BeyondBlame2018: Challenging #HIVCriminalisation De Balie, Amsterdam, 23 July 2018 #HIVJusticeWorldwid17 May 2018
  • RT @Beyond_Positive: NEW BLOG: 'Changing my mind on HIV by criminalisation' by @PatchworkSteve “If you had a dog, and that dog had rabies… 10 May 2018
  • Register now for #BeyondBlame2018: Challenging #HIVCriminalisation De Balie, Amsterdam, 23 July 2018… https://t.co/9xAvewQRBV 09 May 2018
  • Register now for #BeyondBlame2018: Challenging #HIVCriminalisation, De Balie, Amsterdam, 23 July 2018… https://t.co/90XJUNnqFj 09 May 2018
  • Mexico: Supreme Court finds Veracruz law criminalising ‘wilful transmission’ of HIV and STIs to be unconstitutional… https://t.co/GhT3Fbun0y 01 May 2018
  • RT @Bojorquez: The Mexican Supreme Cort rules unconstitutional to criminalize people living with HIV/AIDS and other STI's in the state of V… 01 May 2018
  • RT @EbaPatrick: Les ONG francophones se réunissent pour étudier les stratégies contre la pénalisation du VIH #AFRAVIH2018 @MalecheAllan @HI27 Apr 2018
  • RT @MalecheAllan: In 2014 we worked with @commonwealthorg to analyze our HIV laws in Kenya & identified the punitive ones https://t.co/70Gq… 27 Apr 2018
  • RT @UNDP: 6 years ago, @HIVLawCom showed the 🌎 how bad laws & policies are holding back progress on HIV. It’s time to revisit the discussio… 27 Apr 2018
  • RT @Synergiaihr: Edwin J. Bernard, @HIVJusticeNet : criminalization of HIV is ineffective & targets vulnerable communities. “Kerry is HIV p… 27 Apr 2018
  • RT @AAI_AIDSwatch: @HIVJusticeNet Edwin Bernard speaks to the need to educate lawmakers who think they are doing good by introducing #hiv t… 27 Apr 2018
  • RT @napwha: We've two ideas for the cover of the upcoming issue of Positive Living. Which one we run is up to you: white or black..? https:… 11 Apr 2018
  • RT @kenpinkela: The Eloquent and Inspiring Justice Edwin Cameron - #Stigma and the Role of Courts: The Disquieting Case of #AIDS https://t.… 10 Apr 2018
  • RT @iasociety: 68 countries and 98 jurisdictions have specific #HIV criminalization laws in place. IAS Member and @HIVJusticeNet Global Coo… 10 Apr 2018
  • Thanks to Cecile Kazatchkine from @AIDSLAW for leading on HIV JUSTICE WORLDWIDE's support of an emerging Francophon… https://t.co/Q18WDqaWTC 10 Apr 2018
  • Thanks @nicheholas. As you know, the indefatiguable @o_g_ford pulled all this together for @uspwn on behalf of HIV… https://t.co/fX6ZdLBW5w 10 Apr 2018
  • RT @AIDSLAW: Webinar: Making Media Work for HIV Justice - April 5 11 a.m. ET. Explore material from the HIV Justice toolkit, and hear from… 04 Apr 2018

In a plenary presentation at the 17th International AIDS Conference in 2008, South Africa’s Justice Cameron called for a global campaign against what had become known simply as ‘criminalisation’, declaring: “HIV is a virus, not a crime.”1 Cameron characterised HIV exposure and transmission laws as ‘hostile’ to HIV prevention and treatment, and suggested that stigma both impelled such laws and was reinforced by them. “Prosecutions for HIV transmissions and exposure and the chilling content of the laws themselves reinforce the idea of HIV as a shameful, disgraceful, unworthy condition requiring isolation and ostracism”, he said.1

Cameron’s speech was the vocalisation of a growing movement among HIV advocates, academics and civil society organisations. In a joint policy brief issued during the week of the conference, UNAIDS and the United Nations Development Programme advised governments to repeal existing laws and not to pass new HIV-specific criminal laws. The brief argued that a human-rights approach to HIV – as opposed to a retributive and coercive approach – would benefit public health. It noted that existing assault or homicide laws could still be used to prosecute “exceptional cases of intentional transmission”, which was defined as “wilful and knowing behaviour with the purpose of transmitting the virus”.2

Nevertheless, at least eight countries (Burkina Faso, Cape Verde, Chad, Democratic Republic of Congo, Equatorial Guinea, Mauritania, Singapore and Tanzania) enacted new laws criminalising HIV exposure and transmission in the months following the conference. Such laws are currently proposed or under discussion in many more countries or jurisdictions (including Cameroon, China, Comoros, Ecuador, Gambia, Ivory Coast, Liberia, Malawi, Mozambique, Uganda, Nebraska, New York and West Virginia in the United States, and Zambia). See the chapter: Details for further information.

A new model law has been developed for the Southern African Development Community (SADC; www.sadc.int), which comprises Angola, Botswana, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Lesotho, Madagascar, Malawi, Mauritius, Mozambique, Namibia, Seychelles, South Africa, Swaziland, Tanzania, Zambia and Zimbabwe.3 It is hoped that this model law will support consistency and compliance with human rights law and commitments across domestic jurisdiction in southern Africa. The model law integrates the protection of human rights as a key element of an effective response to HIV and has no specific provisions allowing for the criminalisation of potential or actual HIV exposure or transmission. The model law, which was unanimously adopted by the SADC Parliamentary Forum in 2008,4 has been received as "a giant step forward" by SADC judges.5

The overly broad criminalisation of HIV transmission and exposure in sub-Saharan Africa was also high on the agenda of a recent meeting of senior judges from more than 15 sub-Saharan African countries.6 At the meeting, participants further discussed the importance of the leadership role of the judiciary in upholding human rights for all, filing against bad laws, ensuring access to the courts for the most vulnerable and giving meaning to constitutional protection in people’s everyday lives. Justice Georgina T Wood, Chief Justice of Ghana, stressed that: “Judges have a key role to play in ensuring that the rights of people living with and vulnerable to HIV are upheld.”7

References

  1. Cameron E HIV is a virus, not a crime: Criminal statutes and criminal prosecutions – help or hindrance? Plenary session, 17th International AIDS Conference, Mexico City, 2008; available at www.tac.org.za/community/files/MexicoPlenaryCrim3drAug08.pdf (accessed 2 August 2010), 2008
  2. UNAIDS/UNDP International Consultation on the Criminalization of HIV Transmission: Summary of main issues and conclusions. Geneva, 2008
  3. South African Development Community South African Development Community Model Law SADC, November 2008
  4. SADC Parliamentary Forum Announcing the adoption of the SADC PF Model law on HIV by the 24th SADC PF Plenary Assembly. 9 December, 2008
  5. Magadza M Judges welcome SADC Model Law on HIV/AIDS. Africa Files, 27 October 2009
  6. Legalbrief Today Judges meeting to discuss responses to AIDS. 11 December, 2009
  7. UNAIDS Eminent African Jurists discuss HIV and the law. Press release, 14 December 2009
This content was checked for accuracy at the time it was written. It may have been superseded by more recent developments. NAM recommends checking whether this is the most current information when making decisions that may affect your health.
Community Consensus Statement on Access to HIV Treatment and its Use for Prevention

Together, we can make it happen

We can end HIV soon if people have equal access to HIV drugs as treatment and as PrEP, and have free choice over whether to take them.

Launched today, the Community Consensus Statement is a basic set of principles aimed at making sure that happens.

The Community Consensus Statement is a joint initiative of AVAC, EATG, MSMGF, GNP+, HIV i-Base, the International HIV/AIDS Alliance, ITPC and NAM/aidsmap
close

This content was checked for accuracy at the time it was written. It may have been superseded by more recent developments. NAM recommends checking whether this is the most current information when making decisions that may affect your health.

NAM’s information is intended to support, rather than replace, consultation with a healthcare professional. Talk to your doctor or another member of your healthcare team for advice tailored to your situation.