- Home
- News
- Treatment & Care
- HIV Worldwide
- Living with HIV
- Preventing HIV
- Organisations
- HIV Basics
- About Us
- HATIP #39, 5th January 2005
- HATIP #40, 28th January 2005
- HATIP #41, 17th February 2005
- HATIP #42, 3rd March 2005
- HATIP #43/#44, 14th March 2005
- HATIP #45, 6th April 2005
- HATIP #46, 21st April 2005
- HATIP #47, 27th May 2005
- HATIP #48, 1st June 2005
- HATIP #49, 15th June 2005
- HATIP #50, 1st July 2005
- HATIP #51,14th July 2005
- HATIP #52, 12th August 2005
- HATIP #53, 18th August 2005
- HATIP #54, 8th September 2005
- HATIP #55, 20th September 2005
- HATIP #56, 13th October 2005
- HATIP #57, 28th October, 2005
- HATIP #58, 21st November 2005
- HATIP #59, 2nd December, 2005
- HATIP #60, 23rd December, 2005
feedback
Give us your views on our work
HATIP #55, 20th September 2005
Main article: Revised WHO guidelines on prevention of mother-to-child transmission
By Theo Smart
Earlier this month, the World Health Organization issued proposed revisions to its recommendations on the use of antiretroviral drugs for the prevention of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT) (see http://www.who.int/entity/3by5/PMTCTreport_June2005.pdf and http://www.who.int/entity/3by5/PMTCTtable_June2005.pdf).
The recommendations were the product of a panel of experts convened by WHO at the end of June, 2005 to discuss important new concerning the development of resistance in women and children using single dose nevirapine (sdNVP) for PMTCT, as well as new clinical findings on strategies that might help reduce the development of that resistance. The panel had the unenviable task of proposing simple, practical evidence-based recommendations that would work in the variety of differently resourced environments and clinical situations that confront healthcare workers trying to help mothers protect their infants from HIV-infection in the developing world.
HATIP published a couple of issues on the subject of sdNVP resistance last year. Since that time, several studies have produced important data.
More resistance
Initial reports suggested that resistance only occurred in 20-30% of the women exposed to sdNVP-exposed women in HIVNET and other trials and in a higher proportion of women exposed to two doses of the drug in the Saint study.
But recent studies using more sensitive techniques to screen for resistance suggest that it is much more common (see http://www.aidsmap.com/en/news/379A4719-2FBD-49F8-8353-E3FDFF72F567.asp, http://www.aidsmap.com/en/news/A3C49CD6-6951-4B70-B872-887600D5C1D3.asp). The methods used in some of these studies can detect very small minority populations of drug-resistant virus — which appears to occur in as many as 60-75% of the women who take it, depending on the study and perhaps the viral subtype.
But most of this resistance seems to diminish over time. In one of the studies, nevirapine resistance one year after delivery was seen in only 25% of the women. Encouragingly, HIV DNA in the women’s white blood cells did not show any evidence of nevirapine resistance, despite use of the more sensitive lab test. This suggests that archiving of the nevirapine-resistance mutations may be a rare event (HIV DNA represents viral material that has been incorporated into cells that will lie dormant until that cell is activated, at which point new HIV particles are produced. This HIV DNA provides a reservoir that allows drug resistant viruses to persist in the body for long periods).
So it’s not clear whether low frequency mutations have much of an impact. It appears to have little impact on the effectiveness of subsequent use of sdNVP, at least for PMTCT in a second pregnancy (see http://www.aidsmap.com/en/news/0507DD7B-0FD6-4A3F-BB67-5E71638EE5EC.asp).
But the potential effect on the mothers' treatment outcomes is more troublesome. Prior exposure to sdNVP did compromise at least some mother's subsequent responses to NNRTI-based antiretroviral therapy in a substudy of the Thai Perinatal HIV Prevention Trial-2 (PHPT-2) (previously reported here http://www.aidsmap.com/en/news/94EC3850-D045-4420-A7BB-6EE22D9B70AB.asp). However most of the mothers exposed to sdNVP in that study went onto ART only six months after labour (median).
Virologic responses might not be as impaired in women who have more time to wait until they need antiretroviral therapy for their own health. Yet no subsequent clinical trial has really addressed this.
One study presented at the 3rd International AIDS Society Conference on HIV Pathogenesis and Treatment in Rio de Janeiro last just July, did report on CD4 cell responses to ART in women who waited a median of 17 months after being exposed to sdNVP before starting antiretroviral therapy. (see http://www.aidsmap.com/en/news/D15A2763-C672-42C2-BE78-34CF7AD207F6.asp). There were no virologic data from this study but investigators could find no difference in CD4 cell responses between those who were exposed to sdNVP and those who were not. However, these women were drawn from the Ditrame-plus cohort (http://www.aidsmap.com/en/news/819CD092-3764-4C00-9C68-66E9BA35AA9D.asp) and also took AZT/3TC for a few days after childbirth.
Covering nevirapine's tail - sdNVP plus AZT/3TC or AZT
Those few days of combination therapy when AZT/3TC is given to women who have taken sdNVP may make a big difference. The selective pressure on the virus to mutate and become resistant is probably greatest the first few days after dosing (while nevirapine is at its most potent). And the rate of resistance reported by the researchers in the Ditrame Plus study seems almost impossibly low (~1.14%).
The question of whether adding AZT/3TC reduces nevirapine resistance was addressed prospectively in a controlled setting by Dr. James McIntyre, who presented the most recent data from the Treatments Options Preservation Study (TOPS) in Rio. In short, TOPS found that adding four to seven days of AZT/3TC after birth to mothers who have received sdNVP during labour significantly reduces the risk that they will develop resistance to nevirapine, and may preserve their future treatment options.
The study had three treatment arms 1) sdNVP, or 2) sdNVP plus four days of Combivir (AZT/3TC combination tablet), or 3) sdNVP plus seven days of Combivir. Twice-daily Combivir was started in the mothers during labour and in their babies as soon as possible after birth.
The sdNVP arm was discontinued after an interim analysis of HIV resistance data at weeks two and six showed that nine of the 18 women (50%) randomised to receive single dose nevirapine alone had NNRTI resistance compared to 4 out of 43 (10%).
Data on the remaining 226 mothers and 228 infants who were enrolled at the time of the closure of the sdNVP arm are in the table below.
|
sdNVP |
sdNVP plus 4 days AZT/3TC |
sdNVP plus 7 days AZT/3TC |
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Number who developed resistance /number in treatment arm (%) |
41/68(60) |
8/67(12) |
7/68(10) |
|
Baseline viral load (median) |
23,200 |
24,700 |
35,000 |
|
Viral load at nadir (median) |
8,300 |
< 400 |
436 |
No resistance to AZT/3TC was detected in the study. However, adding AZT/3TC significantly reduced the rate of NNRTI resistance among mothers from 60% to 12% (4 days) and 10% (7 days). It also greatly reduced the viral load which could be of critical importance. Among the mothers who took only sdNVP, the median viral load (at baseline and nadir) was higher in the mothers who developed resistance, (43,650 and 16,600 copies/ml) than in those who did not, (10,600 and 4,160 copies/ml).
The total infection rate at 6 weeks was 10.5% (24/228) however all but three of these cases were determined to be from in utero transmission.
Two infants had NNRTI mutations at birth, one in the sdNVP and another in the 4-day arm but no new NNRTI mutations emerged in any of the 13 infants who received AZT/3TC. However, 6 out of 9 (66.7%) of the infected infants in the sdNVP only arm developed new NNRTI mutations.
sdNVP in the infant - but not the mother
Another way to keep a mother’s treatment options open would be to simply skip the maternal nevirapine dose, and just give sdNVP to the infant. This idea has been explored in Botswana, where treatment realities are somewhat different than in the rest of Africa.
The Botswana ‘Mashi’ study has been adjusted several times to reflect changes in the standard of care. Originally, the trial gave all mothers AZT from 34 weeks to delivery, and to the babies from birth to one month. It then randomised participants to sdNVP as per the HIVNET 012 protocol, or a placebo to both mother and infant. Then the placebo was judged unethical due to revisions in Botswana’s national protocol. The revised protocol gave nevirapine to all babies as soon as possible (an average of 24 minutes) after birth. Nevertheless, half of the mothers were still placed on placebo. (see http://www.aidsmap.com/en/news/819CD092-3764-4C00-9C68-66E9BA35AA9D.asp).
The transmission rates at birth were 2.3% for mother/baby pairs who both received sdNVP and 3.8% where the mother received a placebo. Transmission increased from 3.7% and 4.3% respectively a month after birth.
A resistance sub-study found that 44% of women given sdNVP developed resistance mutations.
The consequences of nevirapine resistance to women in Botswana may be more immediate than in much of the rest of the developing world. In Botswana, a woman with HIV who needs antiretroviral therapy for her own health can access it. For various reasons, though, pregnant women do not always present to an antenatal clinic or have an HIV test result in time before their child is due to start combination antiretroviral therapy. Consequently, women in countries with good treatment access like Botswana who receive single dose nevirapine and who then start treatment shortly afterwards may be at higher risk of a compromised treatment outcome than women in other, less well-resourced settings.
Fortunately, there are also increasing data showing that ART can be successfully given to pregnant women in resource limited settings (see section on Dream study in http://www.aidsmap.com/en/news/819CD092-3764-4C00-9C68-66E9BA35AA9D.asp), and from an antenatal clinic in one Pepfar-funded study in South Africa (http://www.aidsmap.com/en/news/0B7338AE-5DBB-43CC-9ABA-9D37F516F012.asp
Some thoughts on the WHO revised recommendations
The revised WHO PMTCT recommendations clearly try to take into account improvements in treatment access, tailoring their recommendations to situations where there is access to the full complement of antiretrovirals and where there is not. When the original PMTCT guidelines were written, such access seemed a remote possibility. Increasing availability to antiretroviral therapy has changed the equation completely — and made continued sdNVP in mothers who can access ART more risky.
Unfortunately, it’s not clear what revising the guidelines can do for the vast majority of women who live somewhere in the middle, those who may be able to access nevirapine through the antenatal clinic but not ART.
However, is it wise, especially in a breastfeeding population, to continue recommending the same postnatal treatment regimen (eg, AZT plus sdNVP or AZT/3TC) for the mother and the child? This would seem to be a recipe for the transmission of resistance when it occurs in the mother.
Although there is no reliable well-controlled study demonstrating that the treatments should be switched to decrease the chance of resistant virus being transmitted, do we really need to wait three years for another large trial to tell us that one week of AZT/3TC in the mother, and sdNVP in the child makes more sense?
Finally, WHO should be lauded for their increased emphasis on CD4 cell monitoring in people with HIV — and for recommending the consideration of treatment for pregnant women with 200-350 CD4 cells.
According to Dr. Siobhan Crowley, of WHO’s HIV/AIDS Department: “Clearly it is not OK to wait for AIDS before starting ART — this is way too late. Criteria for initiation of ART need to be clinical and immunological and may well change with time and advancing knowledge and experience. Unfortunately in many countries waiting for ART, AIDS-defining conditions (CDC or WHO defined ) is how people are recognised as eligible for ART.”
News Headlines
Common vaginal infection may double HIV acquisition risk
Free ARVs should not be restricted to treatment-naïve, say Ugandan doctors
Nevirapine paediatric dosing: adult tablets can be split, Thai study reports
Condom promotion in Uganda not reducing HIV risk, study shows
Malaria more frequent in HIV-positives in Malawi
Efavirenz and rifampicin: UK doctors caution on higher EFV doses in Africans
HIV disproportionately affecting young women in South Africa
Drug-using MSM and transgendered Katoey in Thailand require culturally appropriate HIV and Hepatitis C targeted prevention
IAS: Prevention is the new 'treatment'
Global Fund: donors meeting fails to unleash cash for further scale-up
Nevirapine-resistant HIV present in breastmilk of a third of women exposed to single dose
Detectable viral loads in patients on antiretroviral therapy causes slow development of resistance
Does buprenorphine have a role in preventing HIV transmission and treating HIV-infected IDUs
Risk of 5% weight loss increased in HAART era, not linked to lipodystrophy
HIV treatment dramatically cuts risk of HIV transmission in steady heterosexual couples
Very low rate of liver problems seen with Kaletra
CD4 percentage could help decide when to start treatment
NNRTIs have a greater risk of resistance than PIs when used in regimens after treatment break
Hepatitis C co-infection blunts response to antiretroviral therapy
South Africa: Erratic infant formula supply puts PMTCT at risk
Co-trimoxazole in Malawi: risks may outweigh benefits
Antiretroviral therapy reduces HIV transmission through breast milk
Flagship mother-to-child transmission prevention programme in Lusaka only 30% effective
Mother-to-child transmission may be more common with subtype D than A
Lower CD4 cell count in Ethiopians doesn't mean shorter survival
Ranbaxy says seven ARV products are back on WHO list
Race does not affect effectiveness of HAART: US women's study
New publications from the International HIV/AIDS Alliance
Setting up and managing sexual health clinical services in resource-poor settings: A comprehensive programmatic guide for NGOs (Volume I)
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw28653.asp
This manual was developed to support the provision of clinical services to key populations (men who have sex with men, people living with HIV/AIDS, sex workers and injecting drug users) in Andhra Pradesh as part of the India AIDS Initiative-Avahan programme and the Frontiers Prevention Project.
Clinical management of sexually transmitted infections in resource-poor settings: A comprehensive guide for clinicians (Volume II)
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw28656.asp
This volume is primarily intended as a manual for clinical staff who will oversee and manage a variety of interventions, including the diagnosis and treatment of STIs, within the specialised NGO clinics.
It features a comprehensive approach for the effective management of STIs, including taking a patient’s sexual history, the management and treatment of STIs, tools which may be useful in implementing clinical services, and participatory exercises for those who wish to use this manual to assist in training.
Other Alliance publications on HIV treatment and care
The Alliance is committed to making access to care, treatment, and prevention a reality for all, including HIV testing and counselling, treatment, palliative care, support and prevention. These should be available and accessible to everyone living with and affected by HIV/AIDS, including children and others who have to face the effects of the epidemic – caring for or losing parents or siblings, for example. To this end, the Alliance has developed a range of publications and resources, including toolkits, fact sheets and reports on lessons learnt.
The titles below are listed by date of publication.
Community education and referral: Supporting adherence to ARV treatment and prevention for people with HIV in Zambia
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw23263.asp
Human resources for health exist in communities
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw23323.asp
ARV treatment fact sheets
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw19588.asp
- ARV treatment fact sheet 01: HIV/AIDS and treatment
- ARV treatment fact sheet 02: ARV treatment
- ARV treatment fact sheet 03: testing and counselling
- ARV treatment fact sheet 04: adherence
- ARV treatment fact sheet 05: side effects
- ARV treatment fact sheet 06: side effects detailed information
- ARV treatment fact sheet 08: food for people on treatment
- ARV treatment fact sheet 12: stigma
- ARV treatment fact sheet 13: Living with a chronic condition
- ARV treatment fact sheet 18: Symptom control and palliative care
Access to rights and services of people living with HIV in Ukraine: social research results
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw21036.asp
What is community engagement for ARV treatment?
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7427.asp
Voices from Zambian communities – Experiences of HIV/AIDS-related treatment in urban and rural settings
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7434.asp
Scaling up testing and counselling services – Toolkit
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7420.asp
A public health approach for scaling up ARV treatment – A toolkit for programme managers
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7419.asp
Movilizar ONGs, OBCs y Grupos de PVVs Para Mejorar el Acceso a Tratamientos Relacionados al VIH/SIDA
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw8143.asp
Voluntary counselling and testing – Emerging approaches from Asia and Eastern Europe
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7433.asp
Antiretroviral treatment in Zambia – A study of the experiences of treatment users and health care workers
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7422.asp
Improving Access to Antiretroviral Treatment in Cambodia
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7405.asp
Linking HIV and TB – underlying issues to consider when scaling up integration of HIV and TB services in Cambodia
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7424.asp
Guide sur l’accès aux traitements liés au VIH/SIDA – Recueil d’informations, d’outils et de references à l’intention des ONG, des organisations communautaires (OC) et des groupes de PVS
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7438.asp
The care and support cellule – an integrated and decentralised approach to care and support for people living with HIV/AIDS in developing countries
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw8152.asp
Handbook on access to HIV/AIDS treatment – A collection of information, tools and resources for NGOs, CBOs and PLWHA groups
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7421.asp
Integrating HIV/AIDS and TB services – A practical resource
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7435.asp
Improving access to HIV/AIDS-related treatment – A report sharing experiences and lessons learned on improving access to HIV/AIDS-related treatment
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7423.asp
Care, involvement and action: Mobilising and supporting community responses to HIV/AIDS care and support in developing countries
http://www.aidsalliance.org/sw7425.asp
An evaluation of the MoH/NGO home care programme for people with HIV/AIDS in Cambodia
About HATIP
A regular electronic newsletter for health care workers and community-based organisations on HIV treatment in resource-limited settings.
Its publication is supported by the UK government's Department for International Development (DfID), the Diana, Princess of Wales Memorial Fund and the Stop TB Department of the World Health Organization.
Other supporters include Positive Action GlaxoSmithKline (founding sponsor); Abbott Fund; Abbott Molecular; Cavidi; Elton John AIDS Foundation; Merck & Co., Inc.; Pfizer Ltd; F Hoffmann La Roche; Schering Plough; and Tibotec, a division of Janssen Cilag.
latest aidsmap news
- HIV/TB epidemic in Eastern Europe a 'public health disaster'
- Low bone mineral density common in HIV-positive men
- Circumcision may protect HIV-negative gay men from syphilis
- HIV 'exposure' from bite forms basis for terrorism charge in US case
- First hint of a hepatitis C vaccine?
- Pregnancy, not nevirapine cause of liver toxicities in HIV-positive women
- Surviving to die of something else: AIDS is a rare cause of death in old people with HIV
- New EACS guidelines address co-morbidities and diseases of age
- Small case series looks at etravirine during pregnancy
- Protease inhibitor monotherapy as a maintenance regimen: are we edging towards acceptance?