Campaigns to circumcise tens of thousands of men in southern
Africa are falling victim to lingering acceptability issues six years after the
procedure was first recommended to help prevent HIV infection, according to
speakers at the 2nd International Conference for the Social Sciences and
Humanities in HIV in Paris last week.
The World Health Organization (WHO) and UNAIDS began
recommending medical male circumcision as an HIV prevention tool in 2007,
following three large-scale randomised clinical trials. Conducted in Kenya,
South Africa and Uganda, these trials found that medical male circumcision reduced
a man’s risk of contracting HIV by about 60%. Following international
recommendations, high HIV-prevalence countries in both east and southern Africa
announced plans for large-scale circumcision campaigns.
Now researchers say campaigns in Swaziland, Botswana and
Malawi are failing due to concerns from men, communities and countries about
whether medical male circumcision is appropriate for them.
Programmes have paid insufficient attention to the social meaning of circumcision in different settings
Social scientists at the Paris meeting argued that those
implementing medical male circumcision had paid insufficient attention to the
social meaning of circumcision in different settings (it is often a marker of
ethnic or religious difference, or associated with a particular form of
masculinity). While there is evidence that the intervention has efficacy (in
ideal conditions), it will only be effective (in real-world settings) in
certain circumstances, when contextual factors including social networks,
political debates and cultural values are favourable.
Biomedical researchers had “divorced any sort of
understanding of the efficacy of these tools from how they operate in real
people’s lives”, said Richard Parker of Columbia University. “That’s what’s
missing from the evidence,” he said, arguing for more social science research
to shed light on the issue.
Threats to masculinity, tradition and sovereignty
In Swaziland, about one-quarter of all people between the
ages of 15 and 49 are estimated to be living with HIV. With the world’s highest
HIV-prevalence rate, Swaziland was an early adopter of WHO recommendations. In
2009, the country developed plans to circumcise 150,000 males within two years.
But by 2011, the
country had only met about 12% of this target, according to Alfred Khehla
Adams of the Universiteit van Amsterdam.
To find out why circumcision had been so unpopular among
Swazi men, Adams interviewed men in the Kwaluseni district of Manzini,
Swaziland through a mix of focus group discussions and interviews. He found
that because men feared reduced sexual pleasure and possible adverse effects,
Swazi men felt the procedure threatened their notions of manhood.
“A real Swazi man is defined as someone who has a wife and
children, and is able to take care of family,” Adams told the conference. “In
order to have a wife and children, a man has to be sexually functional – the
issue of circumcision introduced a threat to this.”
Nonetheless, the three large randomised clinical trials found
that only a small percentage, between 1.5 and 3.8%, of circumcisions resulted
in complications such as wounds or swelling.
Men also reported that they did not see the value in medical
male circumcision when continued condom use was still advised following the
“They tell you to circumcise and also use condoms, why?”
said one uncircumcised man during a focus group. “This thing is not 100% effective
so why don’t you just leave the circumcision thing and condomise?”
Research from Botswana also points to lingering
acceptability issues in the country, which in 2009 committed to medically
circumcise 100,000 men each year. In 2012, the country was able to circumcise
about 40,000 men, falling short of the targets that it is under pressure from
the World Health Organization to meet, according to Masego Thamuku of the
University of Bergen.
Conducting research in Mochudi, Botswana, Thamuku found that
national circumcision campaigns that were initially well received by
traditional leaders and communities had fallen out of favour. This was largely
due to the way campaigns have been publicised and carried out among Tswana
communities that already practice traditional circumcision via traditional
Public campaigns breached notions of privacy and secrecy attached to traditional circumcision
“In 2009, three cohorts of initiation schools were brought
into the clinic to be circumcised,” said Thamuku during her presentation at the
Paris conference. “In 2011, everything turned all around – the public campaigns
had breached traditional privacy.”
Not only had campaigns using radio and public events, as
well as female nurses, breached notions of privacy and secrecy attached to
traditional circumcision, but also they were seen to have eroded the kind of
kinship fostered by traditional schools in which men learned the rules of
manhood as part of a rite of passage. Following from this, Thamuku’s interviews
with men and implementers of circumcision revealed that there were doubts in
the community as to whether medically circumcised men could be seen as “real
men” alongside those who had been traditionally cut.
Justin Parkhurst of the London School of Hygiene and
Tropical Medicine suggested that the government of Malawi had actively resisted
international pressure to implement a prevention method imposed on it by donors.
While medical male circumcision is usually framed as a
technical issue, Parkhurst said that it could be deeply political. In Malawi,
information about circumcision was understood in the context of tensions
between Christians and Muslims. Local knowledge – such as higher HIV prevalence
in regions with high traditional circumcision rates – was privileged and the
findings of international researchers questioned. Resistance to circumcision
became part of a broader challenge to the country’s dependence on Western aid.
AIDS experts’ ambivalence
But while most speakers suggested that public health experts
and international organisations had been unquestioningly enthusiastic about medical
male circumcision, a very different analysis came from Ann Swidler of the
University of California.
In her view, the attitude was much more awkward and
ambivalent. Examining a
key WHO and UNAIDS document from 2007, she found the authors reluctant to
accept the overwhelming scientific evidence, with the document full of caveats.
The document insists that circumcision should be provided alongside a
comprehensive package of HIV prevention interventions. Swidler argued that this
obscures the fact that male circumcision has a proven efficacy whereas existing
interventions such as voluntary counselling and testing or programmes to promote
and distribute condoms do not.
“The lack of enthusiasm for male circumcision has to do with the fact that it doesn't push any of our buttons” Ann Swidler
One reason for the reluctance around circumcision, she said,
is that it touches on cultural sensitivities and anxieties, including those
around about neo-colonial relationships between Europeans and North Americans,
on the one hand, and Africans on the other.
But it goes beyond this. The empowerment struggles of women
and gay men, as well as a broader aspiration to individual autonomy and self-determination
in many contemporary societies, have powerfully shaped the "moral imagination"
of people working on the response to HIV and AIDS, she argued.
“The lack of enthusiasm for male circumcision has to do with
the fact that it doesn't push any of our buttons,” she said. The intervention
does not require sustained behaviour change or a transformation of gender
relations. “We don't have to train people; we don't have to teach them to be
different kinds of human beings,” she said.
Adams A, Moyer E Sex is never the same: men’s perspectives on refusing circumcision in Swaziland. 2nd International HIV Social Science and Humanities Conference, Paris, session CS13, 2013. View the abstract on the conference website.
Thamuku M, Daniel M Safe male circumcision in Botswana: where are the men? 2nd International HIV Social Science and Humanities Conference, Paris, session CS34, 2013. View the abstract on the conference website.
Parkhurst J et al. Doubt, defiance, and identity: resistance to male circumcision policy in Africa. 2nd International HIV Social Science and Humanities Conference, Paris, session CS26, 2013. View the abstract and download the presentation slides on the conference website.
Swidler A AIDS and the moral imagination. 2nd International HIV Social Science and Humanities Conference, Paris, plenary P4, 2013.