Conclusion

Edwin J. Bernard
Published: 18 July 2010

Twitter

  • BREAKING: Justice Committee report recommends wide-ranging reforms to HIV criminalisation in Canada. Congratuations… https://t.co/wzBfQ2DEhl 18 Jun 2019
  • RT @AIDSLAW: We've spent decades advocating for this critical change. We're very happy that it's a key part of the Justice Committee's repo… 17 Jun 2019
  • Published today - 'Using Research in the Fight Against #HIVCriminalisation - A Guide for #Activists' to help advoca… https://t.co/RlrZsl6yHh 13 Jun 2019
  • RT @HIVLawCom: A new @HIVJusticeNet report analyses the growing global movement against #HIV criminalisation. Six countries saw precedent… 06 Jun 2019
  • #HIVIsNotaCrime! Now in Spanish, French & Russian -- #MakingMediaWork for #HIVJustice: An introduction to media eng… https://t.co/MP08yOzZSx 06 Jun 2019
  • RT @WOLA_org: New report by @WOLA_org, @IDPCnet, and @Dejusticia shed light on the disproportionate impact of pretrial detention for drug o… 05 Jun 2019
  • Thanks to #RobertCarrFund for recognising a global network focused on ending #HIVcriminalisation was work that need… https://t.co/PDdmGewkxL 29 May 2019
  • BREAKING - JUST RELEASED: New report analyses the successes and challenges of the growing global movement against… https://t.co/gcRgWJ0AwH 29 May 2019
  • Previewing our new report, Advancing #HIVJustice 3, published on May 29th, at the #ChallengeCrim intersectional dia… https://t.co/WB3HsGvJp6 23 May 2019
  • HJN is delighted to be part of this important cross-movement project to #ChallengeCrim globally. https://t.co/gp9KDC2Y5E 23 May 2019
  • RT @Account4All: "You have to work with grassroots civil society to make access to justice a reality and to ensure justice reaches every pe… 23 May 2019
  • Coming May 29th....Advancing HIV Justice 3: Growing the global movement against HIV criminalisation… https://t.co/bslamJNarH 17 May 2019
  • RT @alisapower: If you have NGO managerial skills and a commitment to human rights in the context of HIV - this is an enormously important,… 15 May 2019
  • Could you be one of our new HIV Justice Network Supervisory Board Members? Applications close 31st May 2019. Full… https://t.co/CfD2P85KoF 15 May 2019
  • RT @AIDSLAW: What this means is people living with HIV can face years in jail and be designated "sex offenders" for life if they don't tell… 23 Apr 2019
  • RT @AIDSLAW: Of greatest concern is that the BCPS has refused to clearly rule out prosecuting people who use condoms. A correctly used cond… 23 Apr 2019
  • RT @AIDSLAW: The @BCProsecution Service has announced a new policy on prosecuting allegations of HIV non-disclosure. But it falls short. Pe… 23 Apr 2019
  • The HIV JUSTICE WORLDWIDE website is now available in Russian. Join the movement to end HIV criminalisation!… https://t.co/gfLFms1qTW 07 Mar 2019
  • Веб-сайт HIV JUSTICE WORLDWIDE теперь доступен на русском языке. Присоединяйтесь к движению, чтобы положить конец… https://t.co/O3LBva7niW 07 Mar 2019
  • RT @BurtonTracey: @GlobalFund @UNDP @Follow_SALC Strategic litigation, legal defense + advocacy efforts are vital tools to counter the crim… 06 Mar 2019

Unprotected sex with an HIV-positive individual does not inevitably lead to HIV transmission. HIV exposure is also extremely unlikely when there is not enough infectious virus in sexual fluids due to successful antiretroviral treatment. Neither are spitting, biting and throwing body fluids significant risks of HIV exposure.

The gulf between the criminal justice system's understanding of HIV-related risk and risk based on the latest scientific evidence can be illustrated by two recent cases in the United States. In one, during sentencing for a single one-off unprotected oral-sex encounter between two men where the complainant was not infected, a United States judge stated that the risk was "just like if you would have shot a gun".1 In another case the prosecutor likened unprotected sex to "playing with a loaded gun, playing Russian roulette".2 The comparisons between unprotected sex and Russian roulette are inaccurate at best and inflammatory at worst.

This misunderstanding of risk may be understandable given the language of well-meaning public figures who unhelpfully compare the risk of unprotected sex to Russian roulette. For example, pop icon and HIV-awareness spokesperson for the MAC Foundation, Lady Gaga, recently gave an interview where she said: "We all know that having sex with a condom is a negotiation but it is Russian roulette."3

However, in Russian roulette there is a one-in-six chance that a bullet will enter your head. Here the risk of harm and the risk of death are closely allied. However, the estimated average risk of HIV transmission during even the riskiest sexual act – receptive, unprotected anal intercourse to ejaculation where the insertive partner is neither wearing a condom nor receiving antiretroviral treatment – is 1-in-70. In addition, should transmission occur, the most recent studies from high-income settings suggest that, due to improved treatments, someone infected with HIV today would have a similar life expectancy to their HIV-negative counterpart.4

The risk of a single encounter of unprotected sex with an HIV-positive individual on successful antiretroviral therapy is, in fact, even lower than the lifetime risk of being killed by lightning. According to the United States National Safety Council, the lifetime risk of dying after being struck by lightning is 1 in 81,701.5 According to the Swiss Federal AIDS Commission, the per-act risk of HIV transmission for someone under regular medical care, on antiretroviral with an undetectable viral load for longer than six months and with no other sexually transmitted infections is around 1 in 100,000.6

This chapter has shown that criminalising HIV exposure or transmission on the basis of the risk conferred by the act or acts in question raises many issues about how courts and lawmakers frame the nature of such risks. Scientific perspectives on HIV-risk levels are based on a wealth of evidence collected from many years of both laboratory and field research. Perceptions about whether or not a person is likely to expose someone to, or transmit, HIV need to be carefully reconsidered in light of this evidence.

References

  1. Stegmeir M Plainfield man gets 25 years for transmitting HIV. WCF Courier, 1 May 2009
  2. Womack AM ‘HIV-positive man sentenced for not disclosing his diagnosis to sexual partner. www.macon.com, 13 Jan 2009
  3. Sky News Lady Gaga's Message To Fans: 'Have Safe Sex'. news.sky.com/skynews, 1 March 2010
  4. Cairns G Many patients diagnosed with HIV today will have normal life expectancies, European studies find. aidsmap.com. Available online at: www.aidsmap.com/page/1437877/, 22 February 2010
  5. National Safety Council Understand the Latest Injury Trends: Injury Facts 2010 Edition NSC, 2010
  6. Vernazza P et al. Les personnes séropositives ne souffrant d’aucune autre MST et suivant un traitment antirétroviral efficace ne transmettent pas le VIH par voie sexuelle. Bulletin des médecins suisses 89 (5), 2008
This content was checked for accuracy at the time it was written. It may have been superseded by more recent developments. NAM recommends checking whether this is the most current information when making decisions that may affect your health.
Community Consensus Statement on Access to HIV Treatment and its Use for Prevention

Together, we can make it happen

We can end HIV soon if people have equal access to HIV drugs as treatment and as PrEP, and have free choice over whether to take them.

Launched today, the Community Consensus Statement is a basic set of principles aimed at making sure that happens.

The Community Consensus Statement is a joint initiative of AVAC, EATG, MSMGF, GNP+, HIV i-Base, the International HIV/AIDS Alliance, ITPC and NAM/aidsmap
close

This content was checked for accuracy at the time it was written. It may have been superseded by more recent developments. NAM recommends checking whether this is the most current information when making decisions that may affect your health.

NAM’s information is intended to support, rather than replace, consultation with a healthcare professional. Talk to your doctor or another member of your healthcare team for advice tailored to your situation.