Enrolling low-income and under-insured people with HIV
in one of the new Affordable Care Act (ACA) health plans in the US improves the
likelihood of achieving undetectable HIV viral load, according to a
presentation on Thursday at IDWeek 2015 in San Diego.
"We found patients fared better under ACA health
plans, possibly due to broader access to medical care and medications beyond
those that target HIV," said lead researcher Kathleen McManus of the
University of Virginia.
Many Americans living with HIV do not have private
employment-based health insurance – the mainstay of health coverage in the US.
Instead they rely on alternatives such as Medicaid (state-administered coverage
for low-income people), Medicare (federal coverage for the elderly) or AIDS
Drug Assistance Programs (ADAPs) and other care funded by the federal Ryan
White HIV/AIDS Program.
ADAPs provide free HIV medications to qualified low-
and middle-income people, and eligible clients can receive basic HIV-related
care at Ryan White-funded clinics. ADAPs are jointly funded by federal and
state money, and the states can decide how much to contribute and what drugs to
include on their formularies.
The Affordable Care Act
(also known as 'Obamacare'), implemented in 2014, dramatically broadened
healthcare coverage. Most Americans are now required to have insurance either through
their employer, Medicaid, Medicare or a plan purchased through state or federal
insurance exchanges or 'marketplaces'. Federal tax subsidies are provided to
help middle-income people afford monthly premiums or dues.
One provision of the ACA allowed
states to expand their Medicaid programs to cover people up to a higher income
threshold, with the federal government picking up most of the additional cost;
currently this threshold is 138% of the federal poverty level, which is
approximately $11,500 for a single individual and $24,000 for a family of four (annually). But more than a third of states have not done so, usually due to
political opposition to the ACA in more conservative parts of the country.
Since the implementation of the ACA,
state ADAPs can either opt to directly provide HIV medications or they can pay for ACA insurance premiums and drug co-pays for
eligible people with HIV.
McManus and her colleagues looked at outcomes among ADAP clients in the state of Virginia who switched to ACA
plans. Virginia did not expand its Medicaid program but it does allow its ADAP
to pay for ACA premiums and co-pays.
Their analysis included 3,933
HIV-positive adults enrolled in Virginia's ADAP who were eligible for ACA
insurance. The study looked at data collected from January 2013 (one year before ACA
implementation) to December 2014 (one year after implementation).
While ACA plans provide more
comprehensive health services than the HIV-specific care covered by ADAPs and
Ryan White clinics, there were concerns about ACA plan drug formularies with
limited antiretroviral options, HIV drugs being shifted to higher 'tiers' with
larger co-pays, and excessive paperwork burden for clients and providers.
"We wanted to make sure that
patients would achieve at least the same, if not better outcomes" on ACA
plans compared to those with direct ADAP coverage, McManus said at an IDWeek news
Overall, just under half of eligible ADAP clients
(47%) chose to enrol in ACA plans.
ACA enrolment varied according to a number of demographic
factors including age, sex, race/ethnicity and AIDS diagnosis. People in the
25-44 year age range were less likely to enrol than younger or older clients.
Men were less likely to enrol than women, while African-Americans were less
likely to do so than white patients.
Enrolment was also influenced by system-level factors including
eligibility for federal tax credits and the specific HIV clinic where patients
were seen, with enrolment rates ranging from 14% to 74% across different clinics.
The researchers found that 86% of people who enrolled
in ACA plans achieved undetectable viral load compared with 79% of those who continued
to receive HIV medications directly through ADAP – a significant difference. Each
additional month enrolled in an ACA plan was associated with about a 6% greater
likelihood of viral suppression, with people enrolled for a full year being
over 60% more likely to have undetectable HIV.
"ACA enrolment in 2014 was associated with HIV
viral load suppression, an essential outcome for the individual and for public
health," the researchers concluded. Viral suppression both improves the
health of people with HIV and has an added public health benefit of lowering
the likelihood of HIV transmission.
McManus noted that Virginia paid less to treat those
covered under ACA plans, thereby enabling coverage of more people. "Moving
patients to ACA insurance helps the Virginia ADAP use federal and state funds
to cover a larger number of patients and helps avoid wait-lists for medications
and services," she said.
Asked how ACA coverage under ADAP might compare to
Medicaid expansion, McManus noted that 75% of the ADAP clients would potentially
be eligible for expanded Medicaid under the higher threshold, if Virginia should
decide to do so.
"Those sorts of head-to-head comparison will have
to be done, maybe working with Medicaid expansion states," she suggested.
"We need to figure out how all these different delivery systems fit
together and how to optimise them."